SHARE Share Button Share Button SHARE

A study in contrasts that would madden Jefferson — and should you

— “Whenever the people are well informed, they can be trusted with their own government; that whenever things get so far wrong as to attract their notice, they may be relied upon to set them to rights.”

Founding Father Thomas Jefferson famously believed, as he outlined in his 1789 letter to British philosopher Richard Price, that a well-informed citizenry is essential to a nation’s self-governance. And, of course, that also applies to the protection of individual freedoms.

Citizenship, then, was a thing to be cherished and nurtured, and respected as a cornerstone of our nation’s shared ideals.

It was instructive, then, to see wildly varying respect for citizenship play out in two locations across Massachusetts recently.

We begin a few days before Thanksgiving, in a middle school classroom in North Andover, where teacher Patrick McGravey is leading his young charges through a course on citizenship and American governance.

Today’s lesson is focused on the influence of ancient Greece on the foundations of American government and covers such topics as voting rights, trial by jury, and the rule of law.

Such classes have been required in Massachusetts since 2018, when the Civics in Education Law went into effect.

As a new member of the House, Haverhill state Rep. Andy Vargas was an enthusiastic supporter of the legislation, and he often visits local classrooms, including McGravey’s, to see its effects.

“It was impressive to see that, you know, in his classroom, they were really taking the spirit of the law to heart, and trying to figure out how students can play an active role in our democracy right now and not waiting until they’re adults,” Vargas said.

Contrast that scenario with the one that played out at Faneuil Hall earlier this month, when two Massachusetts residents, who had gone through every legal step to become American citizens, were pulled from the line at an oath ceremony minutes before they were to pledge allegiance to the United States.

In all, four people were denied the opportunity to take the oath at the ceremony, because they came from countries the Trump administration considers “high risk.”

“One of our clients said that she had gone to her oath ceremony because she hadn’t received the cancellation notice in time,” Gail Breslow, executive director of Project Citizenship,” told WGBH.

“She showed up as scheduled, and when she arrived, officers were asking everyone what country they were from, and if they said a certain country, they were told to step out of line and that their oath ceremonies were canceled,” Breslow continued.

“People are devastated and they’re frightened,” she emphasized. “People were plucked out of line. They didn’t cancel the whole ceremony.”

What a shameful display, and in the “Cradle of Liberty,” no less.

One wonders how that would go over in Mr. McGravey’s North Andover civics class.

Later this year, the school’s eighth-graders will visit a replica of the U.S. Senate chamber at the Edward M. Kennedy Institute in Boston. They’ll get a chance to debate and vote as if they were lawmakers serving their fellow citizens.

We can’t imagine any of them will advocate for yanking someone out of the line minutes before they take an oath to the country.

SHARE Share Button Share Button SHARE